Postgraduate Dissertation


International Moral Concern: A Normative Case Study of the International Criminal Court and the United States

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to examine the developments in the international community that contributed to the inclusion of individuals into the moral considerations of international institutions. The objective of the research is to identify who the international community considered to be ‘worthy’ of moral consideration and how that conception helped shape a permanent international court to preserve the international normative values seen within the international community. The study begins with a theoretical exploration of normative IR theory with influences from the English School and constructivism and their association with the debates between communitarianism/cosmopolitanism, deontology/consequentialism, and pluralism/solidarism. Then, the study examines these normative trends within global governance and international human rights law. It explores the norms presented by state and non-state actors alike and their shared considerations for the wellbeing of individuals as well as the state itself. The study also individually analyzes how the moral considerations of states and individuals culminates in the International Criminal Court, notions of individual accountability, and the principle of complementarity. It also evaluates the deviancy of the United States towards this growing trend in the international community. The study concludes that while the international community begins to fit into a middle-ground between the normative IR theory debates, the foundational structure of the US and its role as ‘the world police’ prevents it from accepting and adapting to these new norms. Key Words: International Criminal Court, United States, normative theory, cosmopolitanism, communitarianism, international community, world society


Links to resources

The full text of these resource are only available to Oxford Brookes staff and students. Please login to RADAR if you are a student or member of staff


Authors

Phillips, Morgan

Contributors

Rights Holders: Phillips, Morgan
Supervisors: Ford, Lucy

Oxford Brookes departments

Department of Social Sciences

Degree programme

MA International Relations

Year

2020


© Phillips, Morgan
Published by Oxford Brookes University
All rights reserved

Details